June 11th, 2010 by Jeremy
This is a response to a comment to the aforementioned post made by Shawn, an author on PhilosophyBlog.com:
There is no such thing as Private Tyranny. The term “Private” refers to the “private sector”, or the group of people whose financial income and spendings are done so outside of Government programs or businesses- excluding taxes. The private sector includes all civilians, their property and all businesses that are not owned or subsidized by the Government. The money made in the private sector is represented by the Free Market, and is done so via a system called Capitalism.
The Free Market is made possible by the ‘privatization’ of currency. In other words, America and its wealth is fueled by the inventions and ideas of Her People. The Civilian Base, therefore decides the fate of businesses based on the desire for that business’ product. This is called “Demand”. Capitalism is the code that allows civilians to start their own businesses and sell their products and services at a price that is determined by the Free Market’s Demand for that product. If the inventor is the sole distributor of his product, he creates Demand by offering it as a novelty or an alternative to a different product. If the price that the Free Market is willing to pay for the product is below the cost to make it, the business under which the inventor operates cannot make “Profits”, or personal return for the product being offered, and so goes out of business. If the business profits from the product, its doors stay open for as long as there is a demand for the product. Therefore, to define the Free Market’s term “Competition”, the business must both continue to generate demand for its product; either by advertising it as the best of its kind or using innovation to ensure that the features of the product best fit the demands made by the Free Market. If the buyer decides that the Competition offers a better product, the original business closes its doors. As the buyer thus determines whether or not a business keeps generating money, a Private Tyranny is not truly possible under the rules of Capitalism.
However, Public Tyranny is always possible. The term “Public” refers to the “Public Sector”, which includes all assets (businesses, land and services) that are procured by the Government via the tax dollars it receives from the civilians it governs. Public Sector Businesses, like the United States Postal Service, do not follow the laws of Capitalism; nor is it able to be controlled by the Free Market’s demands for its product. Every dollar that is spent by the Government is paid for by the Civilian Base. Thus, through the Government, the civilians keep the doors to the United States Postal Service open and, furthermore, the civilians pay the salaries of the employees working there. Even if no one went to the USPS for their mail delivery services, the business would not close. Furthermore, all businesses owned by the Government are not subject to compete with the businesses found in the Private Sector. If all other mail services went out of business, the USPS would essentially be a monopoly. It is because of this lack of control that the civilian base has on this kind of business that Public Tyranny is possible.
One may bring up Monopolies and Scams. Both of these are illegal and should be dealt with individually, as determined by the losses these create in the Free Market. The Free Market itself should not be punished for the unlawful acts of but a handful of businesses- because if the Free Market is being punished, so are you.
Via the Free Market, American Citizens are given the power to live and sustain themselves outside of the means of Government Provisions (which are paid for by the Citizens anyways). If you are buying from a business that needs your purchase of its product to survive, you are most likely buying a good product. By buying from the Government, you are getting the absolute minimum that product can offer- as that business has no fear of ever having to close its doors. In the simplest terms I can afford, you are are buying Quality when you are buying from the Private Sector. Additionally, the Founding Fathers never intended for Federal Government to be involved in business, as this directly correlates with their intention to build a Government that fears and serves the People. As Government seeks to become involved in Business, the true intent is to create more dependence on the Government
What throws a wrench into the gears is when businesses seek unethical means to produce its products, such as having them produced in the less than acceptable work environments found in China and India. Public Tyranny supports this practice, as businesses, which make a product in America and pay its workers at least minimum wage, produce a product that is more expensive than unethical competition. By furthering and endorsing the demand for a cheaper product, Public Tyranny places ethical businesses at risk of having to close their doors. It does this by failing to levy taxes and strict regulations for businesses that buy from or produce products in Socialist countries. The ultimate goal of this practice is to force the civilian to buy from Government businesses while simultaneously obliterating the ‘middle class’. That makes government officials The Wealthy.
Gerald Ford is credited as saying:
“A government big enough to supply you with everything you need, is a government big enough to take away everything that you have….”
I hope that I answered your question, though I encourage you to feel free to challenge this information via research.